Grimm Tales – Philip Pullman

All together now: Once Upon A Time…

I love fairytales. There’s just something about the familiar archetypes and characters; the magic and mystery; the adventures, the transformations, the twists and turns… but mostly, I think it’s the storytelling. The telling of the tale is just as important in fairytales as the characters and the plot, whether it’s the oral traditions of the classics, or the beautifully crafted prose of more contemporary offerings.

So, it was a no-brainer to pick up a copy of Pullman’s Grimm Tales, an anthology of the famous brothers’ stories.  The tales themselves are bitesize, with a commentary and notes by Pullman after each one, and there’s a nice range of them, from the really famous ones (Cinderella, anyone?) to ones I’ve never heard of, and forgotten gems from my childhood (The Twelve Dancing Princesses sparked romantic rebellion in my young heart – it was such a pleasure to remember how much I loved it).

But.

giphy.gif

I couldn’t get lost in this book the way I wanted. Something about the pace of the stories (which Pullman lauds in his notes) and stopping between tales to read the aforementioned anthologist’s notes really stymied my ability to get swept along in the narratives. The plots move unbelievably quickly – again, this is something Pullman obviously likes, and it’s really interesting to read his notes on the history and the traditions that explain this breakneck pace – but all in all Grimm Tales reads more like a study guide than a fairytale. Even though it is… y’know… a book of fairytales.

I would recommend reading it still – the study and research that has gone into it is genuinely fascinating, and quite frankly is probably reveals quite a bit about Pullman as an author and his influences, which is great. The stories are classics (obviously) and Pullman has carefully curated a brilliant blend of magic, gruesomeness and humour in his retellings; plus, the foreword and the notes are really very interesting. I’ll just maybe keep it for study afternoons, and not for a bedtime story.

IMG_20160807_152015132.jpg

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Grimm Tales – Philip Pullman

  1. Pullman himself is a tricky author. A touch subversive in a less than wholesome way (to my mind at least).

    Not surprised you end up with mixed feelings about stuff that he has touched.

    Cheers,

    Frank

    Like

    1. Thanks for your comment! I wouldn’t say it was anything subversive about this book that stopped me; more, it was the structure of the anthology and the pace of the tales themselves that made it – to me – feel like a study guide or crib notes. I haven’t read enough of Pullman’s other works yet to be able to discuss any wider trends!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yes, I understand.

        I read the Golden COmpass et al, and that’s where I found the subversiveness. I really enjoyed the books, but was a little disturbed by the undercurrent.

        I think CS Lewis may have been similar, but haven’t read enough to be sure.

        Anyway, I enjoyed the review. Keep it up.

        Cheers,

        Frank

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s